I observe myself and my investment activities and outcomes. I also observe other active investors and their investment activities and outcomes (this was actually my full-time job before). Something I noticed perplexes me: Despite almost all active investment managers being highly educated, well trained, and extraordinarily hardworking, almost all of them (at least in the U.S.) end up underperforming stock indexes.
For example, for the past 20 years, over 97% of “Large-Cap Growth Funds” in the U.S. underperformed the S&P 500 Growth Index; and the longer the measurement time window, the higher the percentage of underperformance (source: link). According to another source, losing funds’ underperformance is about 2x the size of winning funds’ outperformance (source: Figuring It Out, Ellis). To put it differently: Most investors end up underperforming, and when they underperform, they underperform by a wide margin. Clearly, investors’ hard work has largely failed to translate into good results. Why?
Read More »